LCS and LEC Franchising, but at What Cost?


by in League of Legends | Jan, 13th 2019

The main thing that occupied everyone (from League analyst to team owner) over the last year or so is the shift toward LCS and LEC franchising. The North American LCS became franchised and is now entering its sophomore year with the same ten permanent partners. Meanwhile, the LEC is just getting started in that regard. But there is a serious loss of originality when franchising kicks in, and that’s not immediately evident.

Everyone was uneasy when the vetting process began, and with good reason. There’s a lot we don’t know or see as fans. Does a team have a proper, functioning structure behind it? Are they operating at a financial loss? Are they treating their players right? We always assume these things, even though we shouldn’t, especially because esports is still in its infancy.

When the LCS was franchised, many respected teams weren’t accepted. Not seeing Team EnVyUs get in was somewhat expected, but when fans saw Immortals, Phoenix1, and the legendary Team Dignitas excluded from the franchise everyone started losing their minds. What was so wrong with these teams that they couldn’t become permanent partners?

Immortals were universally adored, partly because of their stellar roster and partly because of their incredible, transparent, and communicative owner Noah Whinston. The fact that the organization made it to the World Championship in 2017 — just months before getting rejected — only added insult to injury.

Many wondered if the fact that Immortals also applied to the Overwatch League hindered their chances, and rightfully so. Even though Riot Games vehemently denied these theories, they’re still highly plausible. After all, Immortals don’t have the kind of leverage that, say, Cloud9 or OpTic Gaming have — both organizations have franchised Overwatch teams, the London Spitfire and Houston Outlaws, respectively.

Riot Games wanted to make things clear, and their process made sure of that. No team is safe.

With the LEC it’s a bit different though. You could have guessed which teams would get in and chances are you’d be correct in your prediction. There was no surprise. No one expected Unicorns of Love, Team ROCCAT, Giants Gaming, and H2K to become permanent partners for pretty obvious reasons.

ROCCAT and Giants Gaming were perennial gatekeepers that rarely made a splash — if ever. They were always near the playoffs, and the best they could do was upset, at least occasionally. But anyone can be mediocre, and any team can become middle-of-the-pack.

The Unicorns of Love, on the other hand, often reached respectable heights but were unable to maintain a certain level of play over longer periods of time. Their playstyle made them fan-favorites, but their general goofy aura and overall branding were never appealing to sponsors.

As for H2K, well, they pretty much shot themselves in the foot with their open letters to the community over the years where they basically asked for more money.

Not seeing these teams in the franchised top ten wasn’t a big surprise, but it was still a sad sight. They all brought something unique and different to the table, but perhaps the best among them (in every conceivable way) were the Unicorns of Love.

When I first heard the name back in 2014, I was confused. That’s probably the only reasonable reaction one can have, especially if you’re accustomed to faux-modern names like Counter Logic Gaming, OpTic Gaming, and Fnatic.

The first assumption you make is that Unicorns of Love are playing for fun, but that’s wrong as well. They’re tryharding as much as anyone else — they’re just having a bit more fun doing it.

That approach continued from the moment the team was founded in 2013, until today. With them out of LCS, the world of competitive League lost one of its most exciting and eclectic oddballs. And it’s a big blow, even though it might not seem like it right now.

The Unicorns are also one of the rare teams in the LEC that were able to go from mediocre to amazing (and back) in a bafflingly short amount of time. They had bursts of excellence, and their power level rose and fell with each meta shift. When the meta favored brawling and heavy teamfighting, the Unicorns were among the best teams in the region. They not only had great cohesion, but they were always willing to go for the crazy plays that no one else would.

This inclination toward the unexpected was always their biggest asset. Seems like a bad play? The Unicorns show no hesitation. Looks stupid? They’re gonna find a way to make it work, or they’re gonna lose while trying. You had to respect them, at the very least. They were never playing it safe, even when everyone was advising them to take a step back.

That’s just not the Unicorns of Love way.

Perhaps the biggest reason as to why they were able to reach such (inconsistent) heights was their head coach Fabian “Sheepy” Mallant.

The Underappreciated Mastermind

Even if you try your hardest, you won’t be able to find a coach that’s as underrated and underappreciated as Sheepy. The Unicorns of Love is a family-run organization. They’re as small as possible. Sheepy added his girlfriend as a graphic designer as well as support substitute. Because of this, they really don’t have a ton of money to work with. The pink branding and name don’t help out with sponsors either.

They always made enough to get by and pay their players, but that’s about it. These aren’t exactly the perfect circumstances to foster a competitive environment, let alone yield positive results in a strong region.

But against all odds, Sheepy always managed the impossible. He’s been one of the rare coaches in the West that consistently managed to create results with either mediocre or subpar teams, with players that weren’t predicted to do much. With Sheepy leading the charge, the Unicorns actually had a chance. Their unfiltered in-game aggression wasn’t a byproduct of their lack of knowledge or tact — they knew their way around a hectic five-on-five teamfight better than anyone.

They reveled in the chaos.

Sheepy’s approach eventually shaped a couple of stand-out players like Tamás “Vizicsacsi” Kiss and Zdravets “Hylissang” Iliev Galabov, while also pushing a couple of others into the limelight like Tristan “PowerOfEvil” Schrage and Mateusz “Kikis” Szkudlarek.

Many respected Sheepy, but he was never awarded “Coach of the Split” honors, even though he was often able to do more with less. Especially when compared to some coaches who were given the nod even though they rarely achieved success like Neil “prolly” Hammad — barring that one World Championship in 2016 when he had some of the absolute best players in the region to work with.

Fortunately, Sheepy’s experience and overall value were recognized, and he’ll be the head coach for SK Gaming coming into 2019. Whether they’ll gravitate toward chaotic teamfighting as well remains to be seen. Either way, Sheepy’s one of the good guys in the industry, and seeing him out of a coaching job would be absolutely crushing.

The Norm

Does the LCS and LEC franchising mean existing teams lack pizzazz and novelty? To a certain extent absolutely, but that’s only a part of the problem.

With perennial titans like Team SoloMid, there’s just no excitement anymore. They’re a top-tier team, with top-tier players, and the only narrative around is (or was, rather), “how far can Team SoloMid go this time around?” If they win — it’s expected, if they lose — it’s an upset, but deep down you know they’re going to bounce back sooner or later, and that’s about it.

They have the same mentality, the same approach, and the same style of play. That’s not necessarily bad per se, but when you have ten teams that function in such a way, that’s when things become boring.

Furthermore, big teams carry a certain weight around. You can feel it just by looking at them, but also in the way their fans behave online. These teams are “cool,” and they’re attracting the masses. Team SoloMid, once again, is a good example.

Black and white jerseys and hoodies, minimalist design and overall aesthetic, dominant online presence, and a ton of huge sponsors. Gillette, T-Mobile, HTC, Geico, Dr Pepper, etc. Those are some big names and industry leaders you can be sure will be sponsoring Team SoloMid whether they’re first or sixth.

Why? Because their “values” overlap. T-Mobile has little interest in siding with five guys dressed in pink jerseys, and no one’s blaming them. But because everyone involved wants to make a living, playing and thinking outside of the box is becoming riskier from a financial standpoint.

As a result, we get many teams with no distinguishable identities. Sure, they have different colors, but that’s pretty much where things end. Is there anything special about OpTic Gaming and their first year in the franchised LCS? Not really, other than the fact that they underperformed and achieved absolutely nothing. How about the Golden Guardians, the only team in LCS history that managed to end two splits in a row at tenth place?

Pretty much the same. Clutch Gaming? Nothing unique either.

This loss of originality, which resulted from LCS and LEC franchising, will only become more apparent with time. And that brings us to a different point.

Little Has Changed

Many people hoped franchising would usher in a new era of competitive League, one that’s filled with more competitiveness and uncertainty, but things didn’t develop in such a manner.

Far from it.

Those that were at the top remained there, and we saw a very negligible power shift. In fact, you could’ve missed it entirely if you weren’t paying close attention. It’s hard to blame any new teams though — it takes time to build an empire. But seeing just how little they did and achieved was disheartening, to say the least.

Those quick to judge could conclude that it’s better to follow a set formula of success, and in that scenario, everyone loses. There still hasn’t been a team to break the mold. Everyone is going for proven players and solutions, and that can only yield expected results.

For the average North American team, just being a part of the booming esports market is a good thing, and it’ll pay off sooner rather than later — if it didn’t already. It makes little difference to them if TSM is sixth, or tenth.

The four new teams joining the LEC are SK Gaming, Origen, exceL Esports, and Rogue. Not one of these teams have what it takes to upset the status quo, nor are they carrying a unique identity and approach to competitive League of Legends. Some might argue that the return of Origen could spark some engaging narratives but seeing how it’s not actually Origen (but just the branding) that’s just wishful thinking.

So in a nutshell, LCS and LEC franchising didn’t really change things. Sure, it provided a lot of financial stability to the competing teams, and that’s nothing to scoff at, but from a viewer’s standpoint, there are no evident benefits.

Some teams like Echo Fox and OpTic Gaming also decided to decrease their League of Legends budgets coming into 2019, and how that’ll impact their competitiveness in the long run remains to be seen.

While things aren’t dire nor any less exciting overall (at least not right now), we lost uniqueness, we’ve lost the small nuanced differences that made competitive League what it is. Perhaps things will improve with time, but don’t hold your breath. This loss of originality will hit the LEC much stronger than it did the LCS.

When immense amounts of money get involved, the rules tend to change. At least we can reminisce of the good old times when being unique wasn’t such a risk.

Comments


Leave a Reply